Could 3D mammograms soon be the standard for breast cancer screening?

More women are getting 3D mammograms, which spot breast anomalies more accurately than traditional mammograms, a new study shows.

But there are big variations in use across the United States, the researchers noted.

Not widely endorsed

Also called digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT), 3D mammography combines low-dose X-rays with software that creates a three-dimensional image of the breast. Compared to 2D mammography, DBT may make it easier to detect a breast abnormality.

But DBT has not been widely endorsed for routine breast cancer screening.

In this study, Yale University researchers analysed data on millions of claims filed with private health insurance plans and Medicare over three years.

Between 2015 and 2017, DBT use rose from 13% to 43% of breast-cancer screening exams, and the increase was similar among privately insured women and those with Medicare.

Use of DBT rose faster in the Northeast and Northwest, but more slowly in the Southeast. It was adopted faster in regions with higher incomes, more education and more whites.

"DBT has become very popular overall, although uptake has been uneven. In some areas of the country, it is rarely used while in others it is the predominant mode of screening," said corresponding author Dr Ilana Richman, an assistant professor at Yale School of Medicine in New Haven, Connecticut.

Clearer answers needed

While evidence suggests DBT may improve cancer detection rates and reduce false-positive results, more research is needed to assess its impact on breast cancer deaths, the authors noted.

"Although there is a lot of interest in this new technology, we don't know much about how it will affect the long-term health of women," Richman said in a Yale news release. "There are ongoing studies designed to answer these questions, and we hope to have clearer answers in the next few years."

Two groups that provide guidance to doctors about cancer screening – the US Preventive Services Task Force and the American Cancer Society – have not recommended for or against the routine use of DBT.

But the researchers said these new findings, published in the journal JAMA Internal Medicine, suggest that DBT will soon replace 2D mammography as the standard of care.

"These findings highlight how quickly changes in medical practice – the rate that doctors adopt these new tests – can eclipse our ability to evaluate whether they are helping patients to live longer and healthier lives," said senior study author Dr Cary Gross, a professor of medicine at Yale.

Image credit: iStock

Advertisement